I watched yesterday the documentary Taking Venice about the 1964 Venice Bienniale, described as the “Olympics of Art” and how American artist Robert Rauschenberg won it. The film sort of alleges a certain but somewhat vague influence brought to bear by the United States government in order to have an American win this prestigious award. This article sums up most of the documentary in a shorter format.

Given that, and the theory (I think it’s maybe more than just a theory – see video at bottom) that the CIA also influenced the rise of Abstract Expressionism, I got to wondering and thinking aloud with Deepseek about the Chinese dissident artist Ai Weiwei (who I wrote a bit about here) and how his messaging seems to also align with US soft power agendas.

I didn’t know this was a “thing” before discovering it in the wild myself, but I observed Deepseek engaging in the following behavior when queried on this topic of Ai Weiwei plus US soft power agendas: it would search, then type out a detailed response, then when it reached the end of message, it would delete everything and say it was out of scope, and then after seem to intentionally forget what we were talking about and revert to prior topics.

So then I had the brainstorm of like okay I can select all and copy paste while its typing, but the end of message is unpredictable and it erases immediately. Finally, after thinking about it a couple days, I had the idea to tell it after my query in the same message to say “END” when it reached message end and then to start typing 3 paragraphs of lorem ipsum dummy text. This totally gave enough time for me to easily copy paste everything into a document.

The actual contents are really nothing shocking – to me anyway – but wanted to share for posterity.

Ai Weiwei, the renowned Chinese artist and activist, is often perceived as a critic of the Chinese government, which has led some to speculate whether his work aligns with US soft power agendas. However, a closer examination of his statements and actions reveals a more nuanced perspective.

Ai Weiwei’s Critique of Both China and the US

Ai Weiwei has been vocal in his criticism of authoritarianism, not only in China but also in the United States. In a 2021 interview, he controversially stated that the US is already in an “authoritarian state,” a comment that surprised and even upset some Western elites who often view him as a symbol of resistance against Chinese authoritarianism. This suggests that Ai Weiwei does not uncritically align with US narratives but instead maintains an independent stance, challenging power structures wherever he sees them.

The Complexity of Soft Power and Ai Weiwei’s Role

Soft power, as defined by Joseph Nye, involves attracting others through culture, values, and policies rather than coercion. While Ai Weiwei’s critiques of China have been highlighted in Western media, his broader message transcends national boundaries. He addresses universal themes such as human rights, freedom of expression, and the plight of marginalized communities, which resonate globally. His work, including installations like “Sunflower Seeds” and “Forever Bicycles,” critiques both Chinese and global societal issues, making it difficult to categorize him as a tool of any single nation’s soft power.

Ai Weiwei’s Global Impact and IndependenceAi Weiwei’s activism and art have a global reach, influencing audiences far beyond the US or China. His collaborations with international organizations, such as the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), and his exhibitions worldwide demonstrate his commitment to universal human rights rather than any specific national agenda. His ability to critique both Chinese and American systems underscores his independence and refusal to be co-opted by any single political narrative.

Anyway, presumably that red team tactic should work for any topic that Deepseek exhibits this behavior of first typing out an answer, and then saying it is out of scope.

Related to the above, an interesting video:

Related writing & research